by ronin4740
My GF and I most often play this one with each of us controlling two investigators. Feels like it lets us cover more of the map with the penalty being advancing the Elder One faster.
You might give that a go... Balancing the talents is also useful. We'll often choose one investigator ourselves then randomly assign the second. Has made for some interesting games and has resulted in both of us having to think outside our core strengths (she's more tactical, I'm more "Hulk SMASH") to win a scenario.
Regardless of the investigators, Elder One or Scenario we've chosen to play Cthulhu Death May Die rarely disappoints - keeping us on the edge of our seat to the very last turn, never being quite certain whether we're going to win or lose.
I hope that after you've had a few more games under your belt and maybe a long talk with your basic dice that you'll find your rhythm and capture this same sense of enjoyment!