by atog
Becq wrote:
Slyght wrote:
My group is 7 games in (plus the prologue), and our initial excitement has pretty much fizzled out. I think SU&SD and All The Games You Like Are Bad do a good job summarizing the faults of the game.
So then the question is, what other games do you love that require success rolls on actions you take?
If the answer is few or none, then the theory that Ameritrash vs Eurogame is the main factor in liking this game gains traction.
I like to chime in that this game, from my experience, is indeed a hybrid.
I could even go as far as that it passes as a 50/50 hybrid. Sure.
My biggest gripe against it is that the Ameri-element is well done and Euro-element is complete shite.
If you like Euro games and well balanced, well tested designs, there is no way you can appreciate the euro element in Seafall.
In that sense, the A vs E factor is really not much of a theory but closer to a fact, pretty much.