by dugman
metaridley18 wrote:
dugman wrote:
metaridley18 wrote:
Ugh, I wish I had thought to ask this question before my group got the game. The game tells a story, a bad one, in a cliche and poor way that totally disregards player actions.
....
....
Says the guy who gave Betrayal at the House on the Hill an 8. :what:
Because "I like to play it. Probably I will suggest it and I will never turn down a game."
Also that game doesn't promise a compelling story and isn't number 1 on Boardgamegeek. It's just a fun stupid little filler stop that has some neat gimmicks. Not sure what that has to do with PL though?
Not sure why Legacy being number one on the ratings would affect your rating of it or Betrayal. And it seems odd that you rated Legacy a 3 because "it ignores player actions and has a bad story" but didn't at all seem to mind those things in Betrayal which is even more random and has even less coherent stories.
I'm not saying you need to like Legacy. I just found the reasoning for why you hated it to be kind of odd, just my opinion.
