by thok
(Written to be spoiler free for a wider audience)We realised after a game that a player had completed a high value ticket, also collected a large bonus, without actually meeting all requirements. This happened to put him well in the lead overall. We are now considering what to do.
Choices we thought of:
a) do nothing
b) replay the game, regarding any permanent changes as water under the bridge to be left as is eg new large city.
c) refuse him the high value ticket: deduct the score he gained for it; apply the incomplete ticket penalty; deduct the bonus he collected
d) intermediate penalty: no bonus (its location specific); but allow the high value ticket, as he could probably manage alternative completion route.
e) a test draw: draw a fixed number of train cards to try & match the requirements (if match, no penalties applied).
Does anyone have further suggestions or view?