by dj9091
I believe the spirit of the rules are to lose what have based on the choice. Since you CAN lost a virtue and not 20 warriors, I'd say you'd have to go with the virtue. I think the choice can really only be made if:• you have 20 warriors and 1 active virtue, or
• you have less than 20 warriors and no active virtue
We've always played that you fulfill the request when you can, and when you can't, you then do as much as possible, and in your example, we see it as you CAN fulfill the request of losing the active virtue, but not he warriors, so you don't get to use the "or" choice.
I'd be very interested in see what Justin can provide on some insight to this question.
Don